Roofing decisions

Does roof replacement include gutters? What to put in the same quote

A roof replacement quote should tell you whether your existing gutters will stay in place, be removed and reinstalled, or be replaced.

Remi Editorial Team

Roofing research and homeowner education

November 12, 20265 min read
Roofer working on a partly stripped roof above a white gutter
In this guide

Not automatically. A roof replacement quote should tell you whether your existing gutters will stay in place, be removed and reinstalled, or be replaced. If it doesn’t, ask for that answer before you sign.

Look for a description of the actual work, not just a mention of gutters. Cleaning out roofing debris, putting an existing gutter back, and installing a new gutter system describe different scopes. Your proposal should be specific.

Decide what happens to the gutters you have

A new roof does not always require gutter removal. GAF’s homeowner guidance (opens in a new tab) says the decision depends on the gutters’ condition and placement, along with the roof’s construction. Have the contractor assess these details before choosing a plan.

Use the table to check what the recommended approach means for your quote.

Gutter options to confirm during a roof replacement

Comparing What it means, What to confirm in writing
QuestionWhat it meansWhat to confirm in writing
Keep the gutters in placeThe existing gutters remain during the roof work.How they will be protected, who clears roofing debris, and how any damage will be addressed.
Remove and reinstallExisting gutter sections come off for access and return afterward.Which sections are included, who reinstalls them, and what happens if a part cannot be reused.
Replace guttersNew gutters are part of the agreed project.The locations, material, size, downspouts, included accessories, disposal, and price.

Ask the contractor to explain why that approach fits your home. A gutter that needs attention does not, by itself, establish that every section needs replacing.

Check where roof work meets gutter work

Several parts meet at the roof edge. Since each part has a different function, the terms should not be interchangeable in a proposal.

Fascia is the board along the roof edge that can support the gutters. Drip edge is metal flashing that helps direct water away from the edge of the roof. Our roofing glossary defines fascia; GAF’s drip edge article (opens in a new tab) and technical bulletin (opens in a new tab) cover drip edge. A line for fascia or drip edge in the quote is not the same description as a line for new gutters.

If the proposal includes work in this area, have it identify any gutter sections that need to come off and who puts them back. If a separate gutter contractor is involved, identify who confirms the fit between the finished roof edge and the gutter system.

The drainage plan also needs to continue beyond the roof. PNNL’s Building America guide (opens in a new tab) explains that gutters collect roof runoff and downspouts carry it toward ground level, where it needs a route away from the home. The guide also calls for sizing the system to the expected water load.

If you have noticed overflow or water collecting near the house, describe where it happens and share any photos taken from the ground. Ask the contractor to assess the cause and explain whether the proposed gutter work addresses it. Leave roof-edge inspection and installation details to the professionals doing the work.

Ask for a gutter scope you can compare

The National Roofing Contractors Association (opens in a new tab) recommends a written proposal with work specifications, timing, and payment procedures. Apply that same discipline to the gutter portion of your project.

  • Extent and products: Identify the sides of the house or gutter runs included, their measured lengths, and the proposed material, size, and color. Confirm any sections that will remain.
  • Downspouts and attached parts: List the downspouts, outlets, hangers, and any gutter guards being kept, removed, or replaced. Ask where each downspout will discharge.
  • Protection and cleanup: Define protection of retained gutters, removal of roofing debris, disposal of replaced parts, and responsibility for damage during the work.
  • Schedule and responsibility: Name who performs the gutter work, how it fits around the roofing work, and who you contact if either schedule changes.
  • Price and coverage: Identify the included gutter work and its price or place in the combined total. Ask for written terms for any additional work and the warranty that applies to the gutter portion.

For example, suppose one proposal includes new gutters on the front of the house and another includes the front and back. The totals will not tell you that difference. Ensure consistency before comparing the prices.

If an item is still undecided, have it marked that way. An open question about downspouts should not disappear into a total labeled “roof and gutters.” For the rest of the roof specification, use our roof replacement estimate guide.

With Remi, start with the itemized roof scope

Our quote process uses aerial imagery and property data to estimate the roof’s size, pitch, and layout, then builds an itemized scope. You can review material and payment options before deciding to move forward. We can add gutter work if needed, but most of our homeowner projects involve just the roof. Bring up gutter concerns when we review your quote by phone, and ask us to list any gutter work and its price in the proposal.

Our price guarantee lists necessary fascia replacement and required flashing replacements among its covered items. Elective fascia upgrades beyond code requirements are excluded, and some discounted or promotional projects may not qualify. Check the terms in your quote. The named roof items do not, on their own, establish that you are buying new gutters.

Before approving the project, you should be able to point to the plan for your existing gutters, any new components, and the price attached to that work.

Had our roof replace and gutters. The employees were always on time and cleaned up after each day.
Cindy F. · Remi customer review

Cindy’s review describes one homeowner’s project. Confirm whether your gutters need work, and ask us to put any gutter work in your proposal.

Before you sign

Put the roof and gutter plan in writing.

Request a roof quote, then raise any gutter concerns when we review it with you by phone. Ask us to put any gutter work in the proposal before you choose the project.

Questions homeowners ask

Not necessarily. Their condition and placement need to be assessed before that decision. If the contractor recommends replacement, have them explain the reason and identify the affected sections.

Check the written scope for both. Have the contractor identify which parts will be kept and which will be replaced, including their locations and prices. Do not assume an unlisted downspout or guard is included in the new-gutter price.

Sources and further reading

About the author

The Remi Editorial Team researches roofing materials, project planning and homeowner questions using manufacturer documents, public agencies and industry guidance. This article explains the decision; a contractor’s assessment and the written scope establish what your roof needs.

Put the roof and gutter plan in writing.

Request a roof quote, then raise any gutter concerns when we review it with you by phone. Ask us to put any gutter work in the proposal before you choose the project.

Prefer to talk it through? Call Remi at 385-338-4284.